Skip to main content

Sixty Hours of Terror: “It’s Do or Die”


PUBLISHED: November 17, 2009

Editor’s Note—This is part two of a four-part series [1, 2, 3, 4] on the November 2008 terror attacks in Mumbai.


A line of khaki-wearing police officers stands a hundred yards back from an ornate, castle-like hotel. Smoke comes from one window, and it looks parts of the building are on fire.
Police gathered outside the Taj Mahal Palace & Tower (Priyam Dhar).

III. “It’s Do or Die”

November 26, 2008. Late Night. Nariman House.

Assistant Commissioner of Police Isaque Bagwan was sitting down for a late dinner at his Colaba home, his hair still wet from a shower, when the phone rang: gunmen were shooting up the Leopold Café. He grabbed his revolver and ran out to his car.

En route to the restaurant he heard an explosion in the near distance. The noise told Bagwan it was a bomb. One of the gunmen had hidden an explosive under a vehicle at the Express Petroleum station on Colaba causeway; its timer had triggered. Pump manager Ram Bhuwal Yadav, having locked himself inside his office after hearing the nearby gunfire, was thrown to the ground. Afraid the pumps would catch fire, Yadav sprinted outside; everyone was running away from the scene. Within seconds, Bagwan received another phone call from his superior, who directed him to reroute to the Jewish center at Nariman House, around the corner from the scene of the blast. Expecting the worst, the decorated veteran made a quick stop at the police station to rouse a dozen constables who brought .303 bolt-action service rifles with them.


A middle-aged man, sitting at a desk, talks on a mobile phone. The top of his desk consists of a single pane of glass. Papers are spread out on it. Off to one side is a photograph of a medal being pinned onto his chest; he's wearing a khaki police uniform.
Assistant Commissioner of Police Isaque Bagwan in his office (Jason Motlagh).

Debris litters the street in front of a gas station. It is nighttime. No people can be seen.
The Express Petroleum station, near the Nariman house, shortly after a time bomb had detonated there (Vinukumar Ranganathan).

The team had to fight their way through the alley crowd to get closer. The gunmen were firing scattershot at the narrow street below, tossing an occasional grenade to stir the gathering panic. Rounds smacked on the pavement and ricocheted at random, pocking the walls of the Rex bakery opposite. One neighborhood man, Harish Gohil, a twenty-five-year-old would-be choreographer, had already been killed here. Gohil had been on the terrace of his house next door when he heard shots ring out. Knowing the Holtzberg’s had children, Gohil and some friends had hoped to effect a rescue. They were crouching in a nearby ravine, still plotting their approach, when Gohil muttered, “My chest is hurting.” He opened his shirt and blood poured from the bullet hole. He was dead before he could reach St. George’s hospital.

With this in mind, Bagwan and his men took cover underneath adjacent buildings, their ground floors open to the street but protected from incoming fire from overhead. Still, Bagwan knew his men held a weak vantage point. He was experienced in such shootouts—going back to Mumbai’s first police encounter in 1983, when he helped take out a gangster in a street engagement. The best he could do was try to project greater strength than he could actually muster, while spiriting residents out of harm’s way.

Several neighborhood men sprang to help, including Puran Joshi, a friend of Bagwan’s involved in local politics. Joshi was in his office catty-corner from Nariman House, chain-smoking and talking with neighbors when the gunmen struck. “No one move from here, and keep quiet,” he had said, before heading out to find the police who had converged on his backstreet. Like them, he would stay awake for the next three days as a liaison between the community and law enforcement officers.


Standing next to a six-story building, a man looks at his mobile phone. He's wearing a kurta, a knee-length shirt not unlike a nightgown.
Puran Joshi outside the Nariman House (Jason Motlagh).

Bagwan and his men found three more dead bodies as they encircled the building. An elderly couple was later shot in front of Bagwan as they tried to run across the lane below. He agonized over whether to try to withdraw their corpses despite the gunfire from above. He had to wait.

At quarter past eleven, six soldiers from the State Reserve Police Force (SRPF) bearing semi-automatic rifles arrived on the scene to the ring of sirens. They joined the constables already in surrounding buildings where they cleared rooms and took up positions. Until backup arrived, Bagwan’s order was to deliver sporadic fire from all sides to keep the gunmen guessing but not to attempt to enter.

Late Night. The Oberoi.

The crescendo of gunfire had accelerated as Parambir Singh, an additional commissioner of police, pulled up to the hotel. Almost as troubling as the gunfire was the posture of officers on the scene, dumbstruck and keeping their distance. Only one carried a service revolver. The rest had only bamboo lathi batons. The air fell silent for several minutes, interrupted by a few gunshots. Then came a chain of blasts, which Singh could identify as grenades from his anti-terror training.

He walked into the Oberoi alone, pistol at the ready, broken glass crunching under his soles. The once grand lobby was completely deserted, in ruin. When he reemerged Singh encountered the hotel security chief, who debriefed him on the layout of the complex, using maps to point out entry and exit points as gunshots above continued to ring out. No matter what, Singh thought, the gunmen could not be allowed to escape. Two platoons of State Reserve Police reinforcements had started fanning out to various exit points when the hotel was rocked by a far bigger blast. The bomb placed by a gunman in the driveway had gone off, powerful enough to shatter all the glass on the ground floor.

Minutes later, Singh received a phone call from Hemant Karkare, the chief of Mumbai’s Anti-Terror Squad (ATS), checking to see if a quick response team had reached the scene. They had not. Karkare, calling from CST, assured Singh they were on their way. Singh and Karkare were old friends, having worked their way up the ranks from a district posting as young officers almost twenty years earlier. The brief conversation would be the last time the two friends ever spoke.

Late night. CST.

From his desk, Sebastian D’Souza could hear the muffled crack of gunfire. The newsroom of the Mumbai Mirror daily newspaper is one of several publications that rents space at the faded Times of India building just opposite the train station. D’Souza, the newspaper’s photo editor, snatched his Nikon D-200 camera and lens bag, took the stairs, and dashed out the door. The shots grew louder as he hit the pavement. Though just two years shy of retiring to a home near the beach in Goa, his birthplace, the pull of the moment was irresistible to D’Souza. He ran to the northwest entrance of the terminal, a hundred yards down track from the gunmen.

They controlled the platform. Passengers had either fled or died trying. Police were dead or hiding. Without haste, the gunmen reloaded banana clips from their rucksacks, daring officers to confront them. D’Souza was tracking the gunmen to get just within range to snap a picture without making a fatal misstep. He ran alongside the carriages, moving in and out, looking for a safe angle. Advancing behind a concrete pillar, he crouched next to an armed police officer who looked on as the gunmen blasted rounds into the ticket windows. “What are you doing! Shoot them, they’re sitting ducks!” D’Souza said, to no response. For a moment, he wished he’d had a gun instead of a camera.

The photographer advanced and retreated to get the picture he needed. He witnessed a newspaper vendor in front of his stall get shot as he tried to close the metal shutter, apparently worried about getting robbed. D’Souza clicked his camera. He moved closer using an idle pushcart as cover. The gunmen were less than thirty feet away when it dawned on D’Souza that his light-colored shirt could catch the eye of the shooters. As he turned and darted through the train cars back toward a distant platform, he heard more gunshots but never looked back.

A train was pulling into platform two. “Your attention, please,” the station announcer said. “Please stay inside the train and be alert. Walk to the back and leave the station through Gate No 1.” The gunmen were distracted when D’Souza, crouching behind a pillar, took the first shot of the pair standing together. When the incoming train ground to a halt, about fifteen people alighted and ran toward the back of the platform. D’Souza took aim with his telephoto and got the shot that epitomized the whole ordeal: Mohammed Ajmal Amir Kasab, rifle in hand, mid-step and expressionless.


A young man walks through a train station. Nobody else can be seen. He's carrying a large backpack. In his right hand is a large rifle with a sizable clip of ammunition.
Gunman Ajmal Kasab strides through the Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus railway station (Sebastian D’souza / Mumbai Mirror / AP Images).

10:30 P.M. Outside CST.

Kasab and Ismail Khan exited CST through an enclosed overpass that connects to the parking lot of the Times of India building. On their way across, another photographer on the third floor chanced a picture of Kasab. The flash drew a burst of shots. The pair then tried to break into the building where hundreds of nightshift employees were on duty but were thwarted by a quick-thinking security guard who had secured the door from inside.

Continuing along a back alley, they shot Vijay Khandekar, a constable attached to the Azad Maidan precinct. “I am bleeding heavily,” he told a friend by cell phone. “I am going to die; you have to save me.” Their next victim was Thakur Wagela, a cleaner at the nearby hospital who was eating dinner and watching cricket highlights outside his shanty when they approached and asked for a drink of water. Their thirst quenched, the gunmen shot Wagela in the chest in front of his five-year-old son. A neighbor who looked out of his window to check on the noise met the same end.


A middle-aged man stands outside of a ramshackle garage, holding a large, framed portrait of a pair of young men. He looks sad.
Father of victim Thakur Wagela (pictured, right), who was shot outside his shanty near Cama hospital after giving gunmen a drink of water (Jason Motlagh).

The sign at the rear of Cama hospital read: ONLY FOR CHILDREN AND WOMEN. It was 10:59 when Kasab and Khan jumped the back gate. A full half-hour had elapsed since police at Azad Maidan radioed control that the pair had left CST, and was heading their way. Fifty-three people were already dead at the station, and these guards had locked themselves in and turned off the lights. Mumbai police headquarters was just two blocks away. And still no resistance. Kasab and Khan shot two guards on the terrace. “Let’s hide here,” Khan said, and the gunmen entered the pink and maroon building and hiked the stairs.

10:40 P.M. Ekta Nagar.

Fulchand Bhind’s cab threaded the narrow streets of Ekta Nagar, a maze of shanties not far from the docks and wharves on the eastern shore of Mumbai. Reema Rabuil Sheikh and her mother Zarina Shamsuddin Sheikh were on the way to visit Reema’s sister Ruma Arif Sheikh. They had just stepped from the cab and Zarina had paid Bhind for the fare. “Do you have change?” he asked.

The sudden blast of the bomb under Bhind’s seat blew the roof off of Zuma’s house and left a crater in the street below. Nineteen people were injured by the spray of shrapnel. Reema and Zarina were killed instantly. So little of Fulchand Bhind’s body was left that it took authorities nearly a week to ascertain his identity—though, for those days, the crows of Ekta Nagar picked his remains from the lower branches of surrounding trees.

10:40 P.M. Vile Parle.

Fifty-five-year-old Laxminarayan Goel couldn’t believe his luck. He had been scheduled on the 9:50 pm Hussain Sagar Express to Hyderabad, but he had arrived late at CST. He didn’t even bother going inside the station. Instead, he flagged a cab and called his family to say that he had missed his train. As the cab wended back north to his hotel in the Vile Parle district, the radio was suddenly filled with reports of mass carnage at CST and word that the gunmen had been targeting night commuters. But before Goel could call his family again, a bomb under the seat of driver Mohammad Umer Abdul Khalid, left there an hour earlier as Khan and Kasab exited the cab, detonated. The car was blasted apart and engulfed in fire. It would take an hour for authorities to extinguish the flames and deliver the charred bodies of Khalid and Goel to Cooper Hospital.

10:50 P.M. Cama Hospital.

Viju Chauhan, a twenty-seven-year-old woman who worked at the Sassoon Dock in Colaba peeling prawns for two dollars a day, was in the delivery room, her contractions now coming hard and close together. She was a few pushes from childbirth—and everyone was terrified. Minutes before, one of the emergency doctors had informed the nursing staff that gunmen had opened fire on the crowd at nearby CST. There were reports that they were now moving on foot through the area. The nurses had hurried through the maternity ward, instructing the young mothers to switch off their cell phones and feed their babies, so they would be sleepy and not crying from hunger pains. They then set to locking the doors, but Chauhan’s husband, Ramu, had just brought her to the emergency room in labor and they were on their way upstairs to the delivery room, when the sound of gunfire rang out from the back terrace. The ward doctor came running: “The watchman has been shot.” Five doctors, a nurse, a nurse-in-training, and a midwife whisked Chauhan to the delivery room, and the ward boy locked the door behind them. Chauhan was told she would have to endure her labor in silence, and they would do their best to muffle the newborn’s cries. At 10:55 P.M., the baby girl who Chauhan would later name Goli (meaning “bullet”) was delivered. The doctors pulled the mattress to the floor, switched off the lights, and all huddled in the corner away from the door.

Minutes later, the gunmen came shouting down the corridor, calling out for the terrified to step out and meet their fates. “We killed two bastards,” one yelled. They banged on the door to the ward, shot out the windows, but still couldn’t gain entry. The hospital staff had locked doors and barricaded the entry with furniture. As Khan and Kasab worked their way upstairs, they fired randomly down the corridors. On the fourth floor hallway the straggling relative of a patient was caught and stabbed to death.

On the fifth floor, the gunmen found an open door. They encountered four people inside, including fifty-six-year-old Harishchandra Shrivardhankar, who had been leaving the Ear-Nose-Throat clinic when he heard shots outside CST. He had run back inside the hospital for refuge, entering the ward through the same open door Khan and Kasab had discovered. The gunmen ordered everyone out to the balcony and told them to lie face down. Shrivardhankar, believing he was about to be executed, swung his bag at Kasab and kicked him. Kasab slashed Shrivardhankar’s neck twice and, after he had fallen to the ground, shot him twice in the back. The remaining hostages were locked in a bathroom.

Unsure where to proceed, the armed duo chose to make the hospital their stronghold. But police had infiltrated the building. There was noise on the floors above and below them. The gunmen threw two grenades to force the police back, the shrapnel wounding two of the officers. Despite their carbines, bulletproof vests, and superior numbers, the constables held back.

11 P.M. Taj Hotel.

Half naked and face down on the floor, KR Ramamoorthy expected to be shot. The back of his neck throbbed from the glancing blow of a rifle butt delivered by one of the two gunmen who had commandeered his room—632—just moments earlier. Stripped of most of his clothes, his hands bound tight with his linen kurta and pajama bottoms, he found the abuse dizzying. “I’m sixty-nine years old. I have high blood pressure. Please let me go,” he begged. “We’ll leave you, we’ll let you go,” replied a voice in accented Hindi.

Without his glasses it was hard to make them out. They were young, probably in their early twenties, he thought, and able-bodied, with large black assault rifles and matching rucksacks that sagged from the weight of their contents. The pair immediately started making calls on satellite phones. Ramamoorthy could not understand the language they were speaking, but figured they were describing their situation to people at the other end. Their tone was calm, remarkably so given their age and present circumstances. One word he could understand was “grenade,” which was repeated several times.

In the twilight of his career, the balding non-executive chairman of ING Vysya Bank could indulge in lodgings like the Taj during his occasional work trips from Bangalore. After eating dinner in his sixth floor room, he had stepped out to go to the business center on the fifth floor for some bottled water. A knot of security guards in khaki uniforms gathered in the corridor had told him to go back inside and lock his door. Suspecting trouble, he rushed back to his room and switched on the flat-screen television. Every channel flashed the same breaking story: the Taj and the Trident-Oberoi Hotels were under attack by an unknown number of gunmen.

He had called his wife and children to assure them he was okay, keeping an eye on the television set. A short while later, the newscasts were cut. For the better part of an hour, Ramamoorthy waited upright on his bed, unaware of the havoc unfolding on the floors below. His anxiety swelled as the minutes passed. Then, at around 11 P.M., there was a knock on his door. “Room service,” a voice had called out. The veteran banker was hesitant and stayed quiet. “Shoe polish,” the voice said. “I don’t need it,” Ramamoorthy finally answered.

No response. Ramamoorthy was frozen.

Gunshots blasted the door open. Ramamoorthy tried to lock himself into the bathroom, but the gunmen moved quickly and overpowered him as he fumbled. With warm Kalashnikovs trained on his head, Ramamoorthy was ordered to his knees.


Seen in a blurred silhouette, a man walks down a street, holding a handgun at his side. It is daytime, and he is backlit.
A security guard outside the Taj hotel (Priyam Dhar).

Late Night. Taj Hotel.

Deputy Commissioner of Police assigned to Zone 1 of south Mumbai, Vishwas Nangre Patil could scarcely hear his own footsteps in the carpeted hallway of the hotel’s south wing when he rounded a corner and saw two men with assault rifles. His heartbeat was in his ears. He took cover behind a pillar and fired three rounds from his Glock. The gunmen returned fire.

Patil cut the right figure to oversee his beat’s tourist attractions and fine hotels. A brass belt buckle complemented his crisp beige uniform and neatly trimmed moustache. This attention to detail also applied to police work. Two months earlier, after receiving a warning from Indian intelligence of a possible attack on the Taj and Oberoi, he had drawn up a detailed list of security upgrades—but it went unheeded. Now his worst fear was playing out before him. When he reached the first floor of the Taj, he encountered a chilling scene: a pair of bodies slumped on top of each other, made worse by the howl of a young girl in the far corner of the room who was missing part of her hand. His instinct was to help, but others behind him would have to assist. Shots from the floor above quickened him to their source. He was a career police officer, first and foremost, and the people responsible were on the loose.

Patil knew he was outgunned. Most of the constables in south Mumbai were armed with lathis or, at best, dated service revolvers and rifles that few had actually fired in the line of duty. Patil was no longer among them. After the exchange in the second floor corridor, he charged in pursuit and did not wait for backup. Only the hotel’s unarmed chief of security, Sunil Kudiyadi, followed by his side. But he was still unsure by how much the attackers outnumbered him. He had seen three gunmen. But they had moved off. How many more were there? And where were they now?

Thinking he could see better from a higher position, Patil made his way with Kudiyadi to the sixth floor by way of a back staircase. This was where prominent guests, and potentially high-value targets, stayed, making it a logical place to start. He worked his way along the corridors, scanning, bursting through doors, with occasional glances over the railing down the atrium in case the gunmen tried to slip away. No sign of them. Figuring they might have proceeded to the north wing of the old Taj, he went back to the ground level to enlist more personnel. Again, he rode the elevator up to the sixth floor and systematically his team worked its way down.

Just after midnight, Patil and a group of ranking officers now on the scene resolved that they needed to gain access to the closed-circuit security cameras to determine who they were up against and to monitor their movements. A platoon of over fifty SRPF forces had since reached the hotel and spread out. Along with several constables, Patil took an elevator to the surveillance control room. The live feed from a sixth floor camera at a corner of the south wing showed two gunmen on the prowl. One wore a hat that said YESHU.

In a gambit to see how many more lurked upstairs, Patil stepped out of the room, leaned over the banister, shot a round at the center of the vaulted atrium and darted back inside. On camera, three gunmen emerged and started firing and throwing grenades over the rail. He relayed the news back to police headquarters. “It’s do or die!” he said. Police commissioner Hassan Gafoor implored him to play it safe. “The army is on its way,” he said. “Wait for backup.”

The gunmen were setting fire to carpets and mattresses. “Where is the backup?” Patil radioed back. “Where is the backup?” On the TV screen, he looked on as hostages were dragged to the floor below. His orders were not to leave the security room, but this was too much. People were going to die as police stood by. To hell with the chain of command.

“I am going in,” he radioed.

“No!” Gafoor shouted back. “Keep them pinned down!”

Patil was ordered to wait for commandos. He agonized but obeyed his boss.

November 27. Midnight. Outside the Cama Hospital.

Sadanand Date, an additional commissioner of police for central Mumbai, was not supposed to be at Cama. The attacks were taking place out of his jurisdiction. But he was asked to go to CST and headed to the hospital as soon as he heard the gunmen had moved on, stopping on the way at a police station to get a carbine issued. It was his team that penetrated the hospital to face heavy fire and grenades from Kasab and Ismail, who they had isolated on the sixth floor. At 11:19 he made his first call to control for backup. Six more calls were made, with no response. The seventh, at 11:28, went through moments after a grenade blast critically injured two men; Date’s right eye was blinded by shrapnel. “Central Region walkie-talkie sends out an SOS: Heavy firing. We are all injured. Need help. Please send reinforcements.” Date traded fire with the gunmen until midnight. He was hit again, this time by a bullet to his left leg.

Khan and Kasab decided to abandon their position. They released a hostage to provide cover, lobbed another grenade, and rushed toward the exit. In their hurry, Kasab dropped his rucksack, which contained several magazines and the satellite phone, but they had made it outside. The gunmen fled through the front entrance and headed north, under cover of darkness, past the stone archways of St. Xavier’s College and down an alley. They ducked into some bushes when they saw the headlights of a Qualis police SUV on patrol coming their way.

The gunmen waited for the vehicle to pass and when it slowed, perhaps trying to make out their forms, Kasab and Khan opened fire, showering the van with bullets. The officers returned fire, hitting Kasab on his left wrist and right forearm and elbow. But the gunmen kept up their fire until they were the only ones shooting.

They dragged five bodies from the van out into the street, but Kasab’s bleeding arms hurt too much. They left two constables in the backseat. There officer Arun Jadhav had been shot three times but was still breathing under the motionless body of a colleague. Had he not given his pistol to an unnarmed officer at Cama, he could have shot them both at point-blank range. As it was, all Jadhav could do was lie still. He heard Khan laugh. “Look,” the gunman said, in Hindi but with a thick Punjabi accent, “they’re wearing bulletproof vests.”


Three khakied police officers attend to a crime scene, in the form of a pool of blood in a street. Some of it has run downhill in a rivulet.
Investigators inspect the site where five police officials were shot and dumped the night before (Priyam Dhar).

Khan started up the Qualis and sped off down the dark backstreets. A cell phone went off in the pocket of the motionless constable. Kasab in the passenger seat wheeled and fired several shots. If the motionless constable was not dead already, he was dead now—but Jadhav underneath was unhurt by this second volley. The van swerved past the neon marquee of the Metro Big Cinemas multiplex, where a crowd of journalists and bystanders had converged. The gunmen fired from the window wounding several people, but not before a police bullet punctured a rear tire and sent them careening away on a flat.

Sharan Arasa was driving with two friends to Nariman Point to pick up another friend who had been at the Oberoi when the attack began. As they approached the Vidhan Sabha, the state assembly for the government of Maharashtra, Arasa saw a police SUV approaching. Someone leaned out the window and ordered him to stop, firing a single round into the air. Now Arasa was staring at the barrel of a gun as Khan grabbed him by the collar and dragged him from his silver Skoda. Kasab ordered the other two out onto the sidewalk. The gunmen demanded Arasa’s keys. He tossed them down but they slid under the car. Arasa turned away, bracing for the worst, but he was ordered to retrieve the keys. He handed them over to Khan. For some reason, the gunmen spared Arasa and his friends and sped away.

12:30 A.M. Chowpatty Beach.

Tukaram Omble, a forty-eight year old assistant sub-inspector, was on the night beat when his supervisor radioed about the attacks and instructed him to stake out a post on Marine Drive. Some time after 12:30, he got an update over his walkie-talkie: two terrorists had hijacked a silver Skoda and were heading for Chowpatty Beach. Omble hurried to his motorcycle and stood ready. Minutes later, he spotted the Skoda and gave chase. Khan at the wheel tapped his brakes and sprayed wiper fluid in an effort to shake the motorcycle, but Omble kept up his pursuit.

Speeding down the Marine Road, they quickly approached a barricade that police from DB Marg station had erected at a choke point on the way out of south Mumbai. Kasab fired out the passenger window at the roadblock, but in slowing down they had allowed Omble to overtake them on his motorcycle. Khan gunned the engine and attempted a U-turn, only to get stuck on the center median. Kasab fired a volley out the passenger window that killed one officer. Omble jumped from his motorcycle and managed to grab the hot muzzle of the shooter’s AK-56, but Kasab fired off several more rounds, perforating Omble’s stomach and intestines. He crumpled to the ground but kept grip on the barrel until he passed out. The other officers fired their rifles into the Skoda, drilling the windshield. Khan was shot dead. Kasab tried to get off another shot as constables closed in, but they dragged him from the car and knocked him unconscious with their lathis.


Nine people stand in and around a crime scene on an urban street. A series of numbers chalk circles on the asphalt mark apparent evidence, including bloodstains and a pair of shoes. It is nighttime.
Investigators inspect the scene where Khan and Kasab drove their carjacked Skoda into a police roadblock (Priyam Dhar).

Back at the Oberoi, the second bomb had exploded in the hotel lobby, sending police outside ducking for cover. In an instant, waves of guests rushed out of the hotel, some half-dressed and streaked with smoke, clutching passports, in tears. Additional Commissioner Singh tried to get information from some of them, but most were too stricken for words. He needed to calm the crowd. He was walking around, barking for police personnel to get back to their posts, when he heard more shots coming from the southern end of the Oberoi complex. He grabbed a Kalashnikov and drove around to investigate.

He found a police SUV broken down in the middle of the road. One rear tire was shredded and bullet holes pocked its side. A voice moaned from within. It was Arun Jadhav, bodyguard to Vijay Salaskar, a senior inspector known for his lethal encounters with underworld figures; Salaskar, Singh knew, had been with ATS chief Karkare when he called from CST. Singh and his guard removed the bloodied officer and rested him on the pavement. Jadhav said two gunmen had hijacked the van after killing Karkare, Additional Commissioner Ashok Kamte, and Inspector Salaskar, along with another constable. Karkare, Salaskar, and Kamte were three of Mumbai’s best. “That can’t be true,” Singh replied, thinking Jadhav was in shock. He had just spoken with Karkare on the phone. But Jadhav was adamant. The officers’ bodies had been pulled out of the front and strewn in the street while he, barely breathing, hid under the dead constable in the backseat. “Sir, I am telling the truth,” he insisted. “Listen to me.”

Just then, Singh got the call—two men had been shot at Chowpatty Beach. He raced three miles north under the sepia lights of Marine Drive, the seaside promenade emptied of its usual strolling couples. On reaching Chowpatty, he found the gunmen, immobile, being hauled away on stretchers. He slapped them both hard in the face. The stockier one gave a faint shudder. Singh pinched his nose to check his breathing. He gasped. “This one is still alive,” he shouted. “Take him to the hospital.”

12:50 A.M. Headquarters of the National Security Guards.

It was well past midnight when Jyoti Krishnan “JK” Dutt got the call he had been waiting for. “Get your men down to Mumbai now,” Cabinet Secretary KM Chandrasekhar said. Dutt, the director general of the National Security Guards (NSG), India’s elite anti-terror force, had been riveted to the TV since the shooting began, waiting for authorization to deploy his men. Scant as details were, the emerging reports indicated running gun battles with automatic weapons at far-flung sites around south Mumbai. This was not, he thought, typical hit-and-run gangland violence.

Before receiving the formal request, Dutt had already given the order to suit up. Inside the barracks at the NSG complex in Manesar, Haryana, some 200 commandos quickly strapped on the dark Nomex cover-alls and assault helmets that earned them the nickname the Black Cats. Shouldering special issue Heckler and Koch MP-5 sub-machine guns, they boarded buses and sped to Delhi airfield. A hulking Ilyushin-76—requisitioned from Chandigarh, 165 miles away—was supposed to be waiting, but it was late arriving.

Worse still, Dutt was initially briefed that terrorists had seized the Taj, the Oberoi, and Nariman House. But when the commandos finally reached south Mumbai late the next morning, they saw that gunmen had overtaken a total of five buildings, not three. As a result, a second round of commandos had to be summoned. (Dutt would later admit that television reports offered better information, going in, than the Mumbai police.) The snafus piled up. When the advance force arrived in Mumbai, delayed further by a government minister, no helicopters were available to bring them into the city; they had to wait for buses. They reached downtown nearly ten hours after initial reports of an attack. (Some counter-terrorism experts say trained commandos must be on the scene no more than thirty minutes after the start of an assault.) It’s not known how many lives were lost during the wasted hours.

Tomorrow: “No Hostages Should Remain Alive

29 Comments

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Tomas Q. Morin's picture
Tomas Q. Morin · 10 years ago
If I were in a car listening to the radio, I would have just had a driveway moment. Motlagh’s report is chilling, thorough and provocative. The question I am left with is why no journalist had sought to tell this story in this exhaustive way sooner?
+1
+27
-1
Lorraine Berry's picture
This is astounding reporting. The interweaving of the actions of the terrorists with the lives of their victims does something that these narratives rarely do: the victims have become human beings, and rather than each of them being one of many killed, each death is a loss. That’s good writing. I’m also amazed by how successfully the terrorists sowed panic. Panic worked in their favor, and they were masterful at creating maximum panic among those they targeted. With the exception of the hospital staff, who prepared for the attack and took measures to hide, others simply appeared to be sitting ducks. I can’t imagine how difficult this was for Motlagh to write. It’s chilling, and covering this atrocity must have had quite an affect on him. He is to be commended, though, for the outstanding reporting.
+1
-40
-1
Ramgopal's picture
Ramgopal · 10 years ago
Sorry to point out - “As they approached the Vidhan Bhavan, the new state assembly for the government of Madhya Pradesh” - I think you meant Maharashtra whose capital is Mumbai. Also, I found your piece very chilling and gut-wrenching and made all the memories come rushing back to me. I am from Madras and was following the entire issue unfolding on the national television with pained helplesness. May these kind of atrocities on humanity stop around the world. -Ram, ATL,GA
+1
-51
-1
Ted Genoways's picture
Ted Genoways · 10 years ago
You’re absolutely right, Ram. Thanks for the correction. We’ve changed “As they approached the Vidhan Bhavan, the new state assembly for the government of Madhya Pradesh” to read “As they approached the Vidhan Sabha, the state assembly for the government of Maharashtra.” That was a fact-checking error here, and we’re grateful for setting that right.
+1
+7
-1
JNS's picture
JNS · 10 years ago
Hey, Thanks for writing this. I am from Bombay and when this happened it really shook the very core of the city.
+1
-13
-1
saurabh's picture
saurabh · 10 years ago
I WAZ AT TAJ WHEN THIS HORRIBLE INCIDENT OCCUR. I CAN EXPLAIN MY ANGER AND FRUSTRATION AFTER SEEING THOSE INCIDENT RIGHT IN FRONT OF MY EYES….I STILL BELIEVE INDIA SHOULD FIGHT BACK AS AMERICA DID AFTER 9/11…THESE ARE THE THINGS WHICH U CANT AVOID UNLESS AND UNTIL U DESTROY THE ROOT…I KNOW MANY OF U WONT AGREE WITH ME,BUT MY FRIENDS IF U HAVE BEEN THERE AND SEEN ALL THOSE BODIES ,I GUESS U MUST HAVE…AND I REALLY APPRECIATE UR ARTICLE AND WORK…WONDERFULLY AND VERY NICELY WRITTEN..THNKS
+1
-52
-1
Neeraj's picture
Neeraj · 10 years ago
The best and the most indepth report I have read of what happened in those three fateful days. Chilling to the core. My sympathies to all the families who’ve suffered in this monstrosity. I hope Kasab’s trial concludes soon decisively. Justice delayed is justice denied. You guys have done a great job; I take it as a tribute on the one year anniversary of the tragedy and to remind the world that the fight against terrorism doesn’t end with the capture of Osama alone, but the riddance of the ideology that promotes these acts.
+1
+49
-1
Susan's picture
Susan · 10 years ago
Extraordinary reporting. This is what real journalism is all about. It was hard to breathe while reading
+1
+91
-1
Praveen's picture
Praveen · 10 years ago
Great article.Very Very well researched.I couldn’t take my eyes of the narrative until I have completed both the parts.Waiting for the next two parts.Thank you very much for providing us a detailed account of those 60 horrific hours.I Can never forget those 60 painful helpless hours.I have recently saw some live unseen footage captured on CCTV s during those 60 dreadful hours. I would like to share that here.The footage: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=1e4_1246490858
+1
-9
-1
Aditya's picture
Aditya · 10 years ago
HI, Jason’s blog does provide a detailed account of the terrible attacks. But I have found rediff.com’s detailed accounts and updates over the last year very useful in understanding the terror that went around in the city …my city. It has also provided a timeline for each of the fateful locations with detailed interviews with various eye witnesses and people actually involved in the fightback. http://www.rediff.com/news/mumterror08.html I am still looking for a link to the timeline, will update when I do find it. Praying to god (as that is all that seems possible right now) that nothing like the Nov08 attacks happens ever again.
+1
-15
-1
Srinath's picture
Srinath · 10 years ago
I hate your report for making me re-live the attack…it was that good. Susan’s right; I found myself holding my breath, wishing events would take a turn for the better, even though it’s nearly a year since the attacks :(
+1
-5
-1
Sunish Sehgal's picture
Sunish Sehgal · 10 years ago
I hope everyone who reads this is moved and would pray to god that give some sense to animals who act like this because a human cannot be so cruel and cold. I salute all who stood in that tough time to save lives.
+1
-6
-1
Bibi FUNYAL's picture
Hi Jason, Namaste. How are you doing these days my friend. Thank you very much for bringing out a reality what really happened over there in Mumbai, India. Wonderful writing!
+1
-2
-1
Gaurav Singh's picture
Gaurav Singh · 10 years ago
Tukaram Omble was a real hero that night. Despite being unarmed he grappled with the terrorists. His sacrifice helped to capture Kasab alive and gave India living proof of LeT’s involvement in the attack. @Jason - I remember CCTV seeing footage of policemen firing at the terrorists in CST. They were outgunned - world war w vintage bolt action rifles vs AK series automatics - but they fought back the best they could. Your narrative makes it seem that they were not challenged at the station. It is very difficult to purchase latest, good firearms in India. The police don’t need the latest equipment to deal with local criminals who are armed with primitive locally made kattas (a sort of single shot gun). Unfortunately our neighbour’s primary export of AK weilding terrorists is making life difficult for the Police. 18 of them died and they managed to capture or kill 2 of the 10 terrorists.
+1
+23
-1
Luke's picture
Luke · 10 years ago
Dear Jason, As an Indian I am resigned to seeing more of my countrymen falling prey to such barbarism. Since independence India has lost more people to terror attacks than probably rest of the world combined. Some of our political brass have been screaming themselves hoarse in multinational forums like UN about terrorist funding but the world turned a deaf ear to all our exhortations. It was only after 9/11 that Western world sat up and took notice. The funding networks for terrorist are still active and they are primary reasons for continued existence of this menace. I live in the middle east and every Friday hear the exhortations coming from local mosque for funds to fight in Kashmir, Israel you name it and the fundamentalists will fund it. Security and Intelligence agencies cannot get it right every time. Terrorist have to get it right just once.
+1
+28
-1
Ted Genoways's picture
Thanks to everyone for your comments. Gaurav, you’re quite right–and it’s a discussion that came up frequently in the editing of the piece. There’s no question that the policemen were outgunned at every turn, but that CCTV footage from CST of them watching the gunmen then running away is pretty disturbing. That said, Shashank Shinde and Sudham Pandarkar showed remarkable courage in attempting to subdue Kasab and Ismail with nothing more than a pistol and a WWI-era bolt-action rifle. Maybe even more amazing, off-duty officer Ambadas Pawar joined them though he was unarmed–firing Pandarkar’s rifle while Pandarkar provided cover and helped him reload. All three were shot; Shinde and Pawar were killed. To my mind, the actions of these three men show how outmatched the police were, but they also prove that had more of the police shared their courage that Kasab and Ismail may never have made it out of CST. Of course, that’s easy to say, much harder to do. When the judge at Kasab’s trial recently rebuked commando Geetanjali Gurav for hiding, her only reply was, “Sir, I was scared.” It’s hard to blame her. As a question to readers: we chose not to include the deaths of these officers, mainly because the narrative was already so long. That is, you have to make choices, even in a piece of this length. But do you think the report would be improved by knowing that not all the police at CST were as paralyzed by fear as photographer Sebastian D’Souza perceived them to be? Among the possibilities created by publishing this piece online is the option to correct, expand, or reshape it, based on what our readers tell us. Also, in closing, special thanks to saurabh and other survivors of the attacks who have written to us. It’s an honor to know that you are among our readers.
+1
+43
-1
Isaac Thomas's picture
Isaac Thomas · 10 years ago
Good writing. Hope to see more. Keep it as simple as possible without taking any sides or giving room for any of those conspiracy theorists.
+1
+31
-1
Shreenidhi Raghuram's picture
Shreenidhi Raghuram · 10 years ago
Hi Jason Very good writing. Looking forward to read tomorrow’s piece.
+1
-11
-1
Jason Motlagh's picture
Jason Motlagh · 10 years ago
All of your feedback is most helpful and appreciated. A special thanks to those who were in Mumbai at the time of the attacks for your words. There are so many intense and personal experiences to take into account. And while only a relative few could be included in this story, it’s hoped that they are somewhat emblematic of the confusion, fear and, ultimately, resolve that ended this terrible event. I’ve always admired the relentless spirit of Mumbai and its people. Reporting this story only deepened my admiration. As Ted noted, releasing this online gives us the flexibility to make adjustments based on reader feedback. The courage of several police officers is highlighted, but perhaps more can be done to emphasize some of the systemic factors that undermined police at CST and elsewhere. We welcome your advice. The more first-hand information, the better.
+1
+8
-1
Alison Wellner's picture
Extraordinary reporting and writing, thanks so much for writing and publishing this. I have a small question for Jason, regarding Fulchand Bhind’s cab. How did you know that Bhind had just asked for change before the explosion? Was it carried over his radio?
+1
-14
-1
Nino Mohan's picture
Nino Mohan · 10 years ago
Dear Jason I am a survivor of Mumbai Terror attacks and wish to send you a detailed minute by minute report of what I went through from about 4pm that afternoon till 530am next morning in the Taj Mahal Palace wing…tried sumbitting the report but probably file is too big and not going!! This will help in fixing the timeline. thanks
+1
+18
-1
Ted Genoways's picture
This is a great question, Alison. As the person who fact-checked the article, I can tell you that we did our best to match everything from Jason’s text against published eyewitness accounts or recorded sources (CCTV tapes, phone intercerpts, etc.). In this particular case, the account of Bhind’s last words comes from a statement made by Yasmin Bansi Sheikh, the niece of Zarina Shamsuddin Sheikh. She was among the family members in Ekta Nagar meeting the cab and was nearby when her aunt was paying the fare to Fulchand Bhind. She told Indian journalist Rahi Gaikwad: “They boarded a taxi from Dana Bunder and arrived at Ruma’s doorstep. ‘Do you have change?’ the taxi driver asked. My aunt walked up to the door. Just then the taxi exploded and everything was blown to smithereens.” It’s a small detail, but it’s derived from eyewitness testimony. The instance of this kind of rich detail that most amazed me was this simple description from the first installment: “Standing in the cool, perfumed Taj lobby for the first time, Hafeez Arshad and Javed couldn’t help but pause for a moment to marvel. Arshad wore a red hat printed with the word YESHU, Hindi for Jesus. The polished marble floors squeaked under the soles of their tennis shoes, just audible over the soft background music. For a moment, they seemed to float in the quiet.” That little passage includes Jason’s own knowledge of the Taj, security video of the gunmen from the hotel lobby, phone intercepts (where they describe their awe at the opulence of the Taj), and eyewitness testimony of their behavior. What I admire so much about this piece is that even what may appear to be narrative flight of fancy is actually firmly grounded in reporting.
+1
-58
-1
Ted Genoways's picture
Nino, you can send your account to VQR. I’ll send you my address off list.
+1
-37
-1
Gaurav Singh's picture
Gaurav Singh · 10 years ago
@Ted, Jason - Yes it is very disturbing to note that most of the policemen were running away from CST. But we need to remember this was a commando style raid by well trained terrorists (experienced Pak army commandos and Lashkar terrorists imparted this training) who were using grenades and gunfire to spread panic and terror. Railway Police are not trained to subdue such type of attacks. It was not expected that CST would be attacked in this way. Train stations in Jammu (J&K) are targets of such attacks and have Quick reaction teams stationed to eliminate terrorists. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/403255.cms. Unfortunately the senseless violence that Islamic fundamentalists are spreading throughout India is forcing the government to spend more on security. After this attack security in Mumbai and other cities was upgraded. Money that could be spent on development is diverted to stop these brainless madmen.
+1
-12
-1
Alison Wellner's picture
Ted, thanks so much. The depth of the reporting is astonishing – it shines through each word.
+1
+6
-1
faisal butt's picture
faisal butt · 10 years ago
disaster tourism meet disaster journalism = dis-journed. this is not acceptable without a context…where is the context..??? beautiful writing though.
+1
+1
-1
R lall's picture
R lall · 10 years ago
Dear Ted and Jason This is what good journalism is about. I saw the HBO documentary on Mumbai attack last night and read this very riveting account of the the massacre. As a frequent guest at Taj this rings at so many different levels. The cold bloodied ruthlessness of the attack and the control of the pakistani controllers over the terrorist even in there dying moments was very disturbing and gave an insight into the nihilistic mindset of the enemy. Undoubtedly Indian policemen were not only not prepared but there was a complete absence of training it seemed. Looks like its going to happen again and again till you fight back - It is imperative for all people of goodwill to oppose this cancer that has plagued the Pakistan society and continues to infect globally
+1
-3
-1
james stevenson's picture
james stevenson · 10 years ago
Excellent reporting. As a Mumbai resident I would also like to mention that the prime minister’s fleeting visit after the attack was pathetic as was his emotionless speech. I cannot forgive him for this. The Pakistani response from their representative in the U.S. was infuriating. The police reaction at the time of the attack was sad, except for the heroic examples you mention in the article. That Karkare, Kamte and Salaskar, famous names in this city, controversial and with many enemies were assassinated almost two hours after the attack began, at a stone’s throw from the Mumbai police headquarters is difficult to comprehend. In the absence of any thorough investigation of the attack the conspiracy angle will thrive.
+1
-43
-1
dsi r4's picture
Great post. This is a very sad moment for all the Indians. We should support the needful guys and help them. Our army people are doing a good job. Lets pray to God to success them…..
+1
-1
-1

Recommended Reading